The Smart CFO's Guide to Healthcare ROI: Beyond Basic Cost Control 🚀

Imagine slashing your company's second-largest expense by 20% without sacrificing quality or employee satisfaction. Sounds impossible? For many CFOs grappling with skyrocketing healthcare costs, this scenario feels like a distant dream. But what if the key to controlling these runaway expenses isn't found in traditional cost-cutting measures but in a complete paradigm shift?

As healthcare costs continue to spiral upwards and outpace inflation at an alarming 7% annually, innovative CFOs are discovering that the path to sustainable savings lies in counterintuitive strategies that prioritize access, prevention, and long-term thinking. Simply cutting costs or negotiating better discounts won't solve the problem. CFOs need a more comprehensive approach to effectively manage one of their largest expenses.

Healthcare’s Cost Concentration Conundrum

The rising costs of pharmaceuticals, combined with other factors, drive up insurance premiums. Industry consolidation further complicates this concentration, with providers merging horizontally and insurers integrating vertically through acquisitions of pharmacy benefit managers and clinics.

The result? Less competition, fewer choices, and increasing pressure on employers to find innovative solutions.

Breaking Free from Traditional Cost Management

Anisha Sood, Chief Financial and Strategy Officer at First Choice Health, challenges the conventional approach to healthcare cost management. She points out that short-term thinking focused on reducing immediate expenses often leads to higher total costs later.

A more strategic approach recognizes that employees don't use healthcare as a convenience. When they seek care, it's because they need it. Creating barriers to access delays care until conditions become more serious and more expensive to treat.

This insight reveals why traditional cost-cutting approaches often backfire. When companies focus solely on reducing immediate expenses, they may inadvertently increase total costs by:

• Discouraging preventive care that could prevent expensive conditions

• Limiting access to mental health services that could reduce other medical complications

• Creating barriers to early intervention programs that prevent costly emergencies

Bridge the Finance-HR Divide With Metrics That Matter

While Finance teams naturally focus on controlling costs, HR priorities center on employee health and productivity. The path to success lies in finding metrics that serve both objectives. For example:

• Return-to-work rates

• Prevention program engagement

• Total cost of care

• Long-term health outcomes

The CFO’s Healthcare Cost Action Plan

Traditional healthcare cost management is like trying to save money by skipping oil changes in your car - it might look good on paper today, but it will cost you significantly more down the road. Here are actionable ways to drive better outcomes for both the bottom line and employees:

Move beyond traditional metrics. Stop focusing solely on discount percentages - they can be misleading and often mask actual costs. Instead, implement a comprehensive measurement system that tracks the total cost of care across the entire health journey.

Strategically direct care flow. Design your benefits structure to guide employees toward high-value care options without restricting choice. The goal isn't to force employees into the cheapest option but to align quality care with cost efficiency.

Invest in prevention and early intervention. Make strategic investments in preventive services that reduce long-term costs. This includes ensuring access to primary care, supporting comprehensive mental health services, and funding early intervention programs for chronic conditions. Focus on services that both improve health outcomes and reduce total costs.

Want to learn more about transforming your approach to healthcare benefits? Check out our full conversation with Anisha Sood on this week’s episode of The CFO Show, available wherever you typically watch or listen to podcasts.

Revolutionize FP&A at Excelerate 2025

Register now for a transformative three-day experience in Las Vegas in May! Join us for exclusive insights into cutting-edge AI technologies, network with visionary leaders in strategic finance and explore next-gen tools that will shape the future of finance. Enhance your skills and network with experts from Vena, Microsoft and top companies across industries.

In case you missed it…

What if your finance team could drive explosive growth instead of just tracking it? Amy Ward, CFO of Blue River PetCare, proved it's possible by leading her company's expansion from 17 to 500+ locations. Her unconventional approach transformed finance from a backlogged department into a strategic growth driver. Learn how Amy balanced innovation with operations while scaling a high-performing finance function, and gain valuable insights for your own business strategy.

What’s next…

Can the CFO-COO relationship truly drive organizational success? In next week's episode of The CFO Show, Sandra Clarke, Former Chief Operating Officer of Blue Shield of California, proves it can. In our next episode, Sandra shares insights from her journey from CFO to COO, drawing on experience across six industries and overseeing operations for a 4.8-million-member health plan. Discover how the blurring lines between finance and operations are reshaping business dynamics, and learn practical strategies for finance leaders to build stronger partnerships with operations. Tune in to unlock the secrets of strategic collaboration that drive transformative results.